Skip to main content

Philippine Election 2019: A Case for Migration

There has been a number of story runs on the media the past couple of days regarding the search keywords ‘migrate’ and ‘migrating’ trending HARD soon after the election.  Seeing that it involved data analytics and number crunching, which is a passion of mine and is a good part of my day job for the past 17 years, it immediately struck a chord. 

I first saw it on Rappler. I read through the article and, as soon as I was done, searched online to see what other agencies ran the story and how they presented it. Using google search tools, I saw the first run of the story is by Davinci Maru of ABS-CBN at 11:47pm on May 13, 2019, entitled “Dismayed at initial poll results, Filipinos search for ‘migrate’ online.  Then the Philippine Star soon followed, with a more detailed account of the interview.  To give credit where credit is due, of all the story runs, only the Philippine Star article actually provided more useable content, rather than the usual strategy employed by most news outfits of (1) picking a specific quote; (2) creating a hype and blowing it up; and (3) supporting it with a few twitter/FB screenshots from real people; then (4) making it appear as the overall sentiment of the majority of the populace.

According to ABS-CBN, the data in their report is from a certain Isaac Reyes of DataSeer, a data science and analytics training provider. A quick search of the name shows a profile of a “data scientist” who is the Lead Trainer and the proprietor of DataSeer.  On his profile, this is how he describes his decade long relationship with data, “I live and breathe it.”  Reading through the profile seems to strongly indicate his expertise on the subject of data analytics.

I do not claim to be an expert on the subject, but I have a pretty good grasp of data analysis, having done many business case studies, scenario simulations and business process improvements projects, all involving loads of data analytics. But after reading through the story on the “trending” search keywords being promoted on the mainstream media (of course with their own twists and turns), I cannot help but scratch my head and question my understanding of numbers and analytics.  It seemed to me that some data analytics fundamentals have been flouted, purposely or otherwise, in the development of this particular narrative. Either that, or I may really just have gone so dumb to a point that I cannot understand a very simple story that they are trying to tell.

You know how your head hurts when you are certain you know something but your head cannot chuck out the information that you know?  Like when you see a face of an actor and you know his name but somehow the name just would not come out?  That is exactly how my head hurt the past couple of days.  I know I understand data and trends but I cannot seem to wrap my head around the ‘election results’-‘migration’ narrative.  So, I decided to dig deeper, analyze the “analysis” and write about it.  Please read on.  I promise, there will be some really entertaining $#!+ here, especially when you get towards the end.  Here goes…

The Beginning
This right here is exactly where it all starts.  Our data scientist’s posts on FB relate to data from Google trends that appears to point to the idea that some people in PH do not like the initial election results so much that they are ready to pack up and leave.  This was picked up by news outfits who decided to run the story. 




The Data

Here is the data that created the hype.  Indeed, there was a “massive” spike of interest on searches for ‘migrate’ and ‘migrating’ @8:00pm on May 13, 2019, relative to the rest of the week.


The Narrative

Based on the spike on the Google trend data on the keyword ‘migrate’ (showing the spike of interest coinciding with the release of the first election results) and the FB post of the data scientist’s proposition, the media solidified the narrative, which runs along the line of… Filipinos are so dismayed by the preliminary election results that Filipinos have gone straight to the internet and started researching using ‘migrate’ and ‘migration’. 

It suggests that people suddenly started researching on ways to get out of the Philippines as soon as possible.  Here are a few of the headlines ran by the mainstream media.


So What?

There is data to support the narrative, and numbers do not lie.  The analytics can be recreated simply by going to trends.google.com yourself and you can see that there really was a spike in interest for the said keywords. So if the numbers are true and you can recreate the conditions of the study then this is not fake news! So “what is wrong with the narrative?” you ask.

Let me count the ways…


1.       The Data Set

The most common mode of failure in data analysis is the use of inappropriate data.  Selecting the sample, cleaning up, and grouping the data are always the first things you do before doing any analytics.  The sample must be a good representation of the population.  Rogue data must be eliminated from the sample to ensure that the trends do not get skewed.  Then the data must be organized and grouped to identify trends. 

The trouble with the data from Google trends is you do not have visibility on the raw data.  Presumably, the data has already been cleaned.  Granting that this is the case, the next issue is finding the right search keyword for the study, which in this case is very specific, i.e. “migrate” and “migrating”.  Under normal circumstances, this would be okay as an independent data set.  However, the claim is that the election has something to do with the spike. 

By choosing only ‘migrate’ and ‘migrating’ as the search keywords, we only point to a sample population that actually searched for these specific keywords as an independent data set, not as subset of a bigger data that contains related subsets.  Therefore, with the current data and the study criteria, we can only see the spike relative to the volume of search during the study period, but we cannot make a correlation whether the search volume that drove up the trend make up 1% or 90% of the population that was actually interested on the election.  This bring me to point no. 2.


2.       The Correlation 

Data analysis, especially when percentage or relative volumes are used instead of actual count, would depend very much on correlation with other data.  Had the data been on actual count of search hits, say 2 consistent hits throughout the week then a sudden spike driven by 1,000 search hits on a given period, then from the 1,000 hits we can somehow deduce the relevance of the data against the voting population.   Unfortunately, Google trends data do not show counts.  Therefore, to tell a proper story, it is vital that a proper correlation is made. Without correlation, the analysis is meaningless. The data presented to us through the media lacked any workable correlation. 

Let us try and make some sense of the data then by trying to make some correlation. To do this, we need to first understand assumptions.  In this case, the proposition is that maybe, just maybe, the election results have something to do with the spike.  We can use this then as our assumption. To use this information in the analysis, we add another keyword to the comparison alongside “migrate” and “migrating”.  For this purpose, I chose “Halalan 2019”, just so we are consistent with the hashtag our data scientist used at the time of posting. 

This is what we get.


As you can see, we have somehow established a meaningful comparison between the volume of people in the Philippines searching for the keywords, ‘migrate’ or ‘migrating’ and those people searching for keywords about the election, i.e. ‘halalan 2019’.

Now we can see clearly (for those with microscopic vision) the significance of the data from the selected sample on the report being promoted by the media (see the red and the blue dots) in relation to the total volume of the search from the population interested with the election using the “halalan 2019” keyword.  Simply put, the significance is “insignificant” and that there isn't really any workable relationship  between the data sets to establish meaningful correlation.  This is why I cannot seem to understand where the statement, “Search terms ‘migrate’ and ‘migrating’ are trending HARD in PH right now.” came from.  I personally see no HARD trend developing anywhere in those graphs, when all things are put in proper context.

There are also other comparisons that could have been made to put more perspective into the data.  Examples could be relative volume compared with the recent Philippine elections in the last decade, to see the then and now.  They could have also looked at the historical trend (say from 2004 to date) of the keywords to show the relevance of the data they are presenting in isolation.  But they would not, because if they did, it would be clear that the overall interest on these keywords are actually on the decline in itself. 


Presenting the graph above, showing historical trend from 2004 to date, will definitely not support the proposition and is definitely not in line with the narrative.  So this is definitely a graph/analysis that is not fit for purpose.  Which brings me to point no. 3.


3.       The Driver

There is always a driver – a purpose, when we do analytics.  In business, we do it to support sound and informed decision-making.  In debates, we use it to convince the opposition to see things from our vantage point, if not to fully get them to our side of the fence.  In quality, we do analytics to find the balance between the cost of quality, the bottom line, and the satisfaction of the customer we serve. 

There is always a driver in analytics – an end goal, if you may.  The report we generate in analytics is the tool that we use to get to that designed end goal, be it an event, a condition or a call to action.  This makes data analytics deliberate.  The end result we want to achieve and the action that we want to happen always dictates the way we select our sample population and how we present the data. 

This is the HARD truth about data analytics.  And the true measure of brilliant data analytics is when the end goal is achieved.  Analytics without any driver is an utter waste of time.

On this particular case, we all know that the election is over. The votes have been cast.  There is no amount of data analytics that can change the results.  There are no more decisions to make nor actions to take with regards to the election.  So what is this data analytics report, and the media promoting it, trying to achieve?  What is the driver? What is the designed end goal?

This is where the fun part that I promised begins…


4.       The Keyword

Let us be naïve for a while and assume that the perceived irregularities I pointed out on the first 3 points do not exist and that the data set is pristine.  My next big question would be, “What was the methodology used for arriving at the search keywords, ‘migrate’ and ‘migrating’?  Yes, it was claimed that the words started showing up on real people’s posts on social media, which prompted the more detailed analysis on the keywords.  However, these keywords did not actually trend on Twitter, Facebook, nor Goolge as far as I am aware of.  They were never at the top 10 of any trending list between May 10 and May 15.  Of the many trending election-related words to pick during the study, ‘migrate’ and ‘migrating’ were chosen. There are also other words like, ‘happy’, ‘hopeful’, ‘sad’, scared’, ‘cheating’, etc. that could have been used to at least assess popular sentiment.  Even “#halalandayaan2019”, according to coconuts.co, was the no.1 trending topic on Philippine Twitter as of May 14.  Why was there no analytics done on that hashtag instead? 

I appreciate that choosing keywords for search analytics is more technical than just choosing random words to anyone’s liking.  Having said so, if no selection methodology is presented, my first assumption is the selection was ad hoc, arbitrary, whimsical – and “maybe” deliberate. 

Now it gets more interesting…


5.       The Timing

I always believe that in everything, timing is everything.  So, I could not let this minor detail pass.  I would like to draw your attention to these two curious screenshots, with particular focus on the highlighted parts…


Yes, you are right!  There is no imagining things here.  The claim that “people in PH are not liking the preliminary elections results” thus driving the search terms ‘migrate’ and ‘migrating’, was actually made 15 minutes before the results from the first 15 clustered precincts are actually received. 

I said in point no.4 that the selection of search words, without a defined selection criteria, “maybe” deliberate.  This evidence right here showing the claim was made 15 minutes in advance of the actual data being made public somehow makes what initially seemed as an arbitrary selection appear more of a deliberate one.  It is as if there is clairvoyance power at play, which enabled foreseeing the upcoming trending of the “randomly” selected keywords in the very near future.

Could it be a case of local server clocks at Rappler and Facebook as well as the poster’s local system clocks not being synchronized?  It may well could be.  But in this day and age when clocks (especially computer clocks) are synced through date and time servers around the globe, which in turn are synchronized with each other, I really find it hard to believe that this is the case here.


My Final Thoughts

There has always been that skeptic in me that make me tend to question  things.  Amongst them include my questioning of how mainstream media presents facts and data.  In the past, and up until now, I notice that numbers, data and figures have always been misrepresented, misconstrued or miscalculated by them, intently or otherwise.  This started off subtly but this one here is so blatant that it feels like a slap on the face.  It is as if the Filipino people do not have brains and are incapable of thoughts and analysis.

Isolating a small subset of data and presenting it as if it is the entire data, and somehow making it subtly (and sometimes, not so) look like a true representation of an entire population is a big insult to the Filipino intellect.  Case in point, Rappler claims that freedom of the press is under attack under this administration.  However, it is only them that is being restricted, primarily due to the fact that the government sees them as abusing their press privilege. But somehow, they have turned it such that Rappler is the "press" and the perceived baseless attack on Rappler is an attack on the entire press - an isolation of small subset of data and turning it into a true representation of an entire population.  However, when you look around, the remaining majority of the press are able to exercise their privilege without much fuss.  For cases of self-serving generalization such as this, I take grave personal insult.  This is why I suddenly felt the need to exercise my constitutional right to freedom of expression.  This is my expression of outrage and dismay.

While we are on the issue of “freedom of expression”, that many claim is under attack and is stifled by the current administration, this I say to you: the fact that the media freely and continuously promotes reports such as this, with very little repercussions, if at all there is any, is a testament that the freedom of expression, and with it, democracy, is very much alive.

Please do not continue to insult the Filipino people.  I think we all know what is at play here.  Seriously, who are the people who would consider migration as a means of escape from a 'dire' national  situation?  Those with the financial capacity to migrate! That is the upper class.  These lot are surely well traveled and would surely already be aware, more or less, of the migration processes.  They would not need to do much research, especially if consultants are used for the migration.  Would you have us believe then that the lower class would be the ones that have driven up trend? How many of them even have passports?  In dire situations, the lower class' first worry would be where to get the money to buy the basic necessities for the day.  Also, common sense would dictate that as part of the migration process, the search hits for 'passport' should also show strong correlation with this data since a passport is a mandatory requirement.  But alas, the available data do not show any meaningful correlation to support this.


What about the middle class then?  Well, the majority of the middle working class are OFWs whose search hits (for 'migrate' in case they really are on the lookout to migrate) would not even be counted in the data set for searches in the Philippines.  So I am pretty sure they are not part of that google data. What about the middle class still in the Philippines?  Well, for starters, they should have triggered a surge on the 'passport' keyword search at least.  In fact, if you look at the data on 'passport' search hits in the past 12 months, that too is on the decline.  There really isn't anything much to work with here to make the narrative credible at the very least.  

Amidst these senseless, insignificant data that the media decided to pick up on and publicize, I go back to question on the 'driver'.  What is the 'driver' here?  Better yet, who is the 'driver' here? What is the end goal?  From what I can deduce from the available data, the 'driver' would be to cast doubts on the electoral process. I can also deduce that the 'drivers': (1) are within the Philippines; (2) are a very insignificant fraction of the voting population; (3) already have passports; and (4) have the capacity to migrate.  Hmmmmmmm... Esep Esep pa more.

What is the end goal?  I suppose for this, we will all just have to wait and see.  

To conclude, this is clearly a very blatant disrespect to us thinking Pinoys.  I say to the Filipino intellectuals out there and those Filipinos with considerable reach, please use your gifts and powers responsibly.  You never know when your opinions will be picked up and used as an instrument for discord rather than for strengthening our nation. For those who cannot, does not want, or simply  refuse to aid in the development of our nation, kindly please follow these steps:
  1. open up your browser;
  2. type google.com on the address bar, 
  3. type ‘migrate’ as your search word 
  4. hit ‘Enter’.  

If you need help, contact Mr. Locsin.  I heard he is willing to help out disgruntled citizens wanting to pack up and go.  Leave the Philippines to patriotic Filipinos who truly care for this nation.




Comments

What people are reading...

A lesson on parenting: Father and son tread water 15 hours overnight in the Atlantic with help from Buzz Lightyear

Father and son tread water 15 hours overnight in the Atlantic with help from Buzz Lightyear This is an inspiring story about parenting.  Time and time again, as parents we are caught up in the tide of life.  Sometimes the tide gets too overwhelming that we begin to lose faith.  Tides come in different forms, it could be stress of parenting itself or a work/financial problem, and there are those tides of real physical danger much like in the news above. If you were the parent in this news, yourself and your son - two tiny specks in an infinite pool of deep blue and dangerous waters, to see your son slowly drift away while you just stare in utter helplessness would break your spirit faster than you could blink your eye.   Most parents in the same dire situation would swim themselves to death and possibly hold on for as long as humanly possible to provide an anchor or a floater for his/her kid til help arrives.  Even ...

The Last Cab Ride

A true story by Kent Nerburn Twenty years ago, I drove a cab for a living. One time I arrived in the middle of the night for a pick up at a building that was dark except for a single light in a ground floor window. Under these circumstances, many drivers would just honk once or twice, wait a minute, then drive away. But I had seen too many impoverished people who depended on taxis as their only means of transportation. Unless a situation smelled of danger, I always went to the door. This passenger might be someone who needs my assistance, I reasoned to myself. So I walked to the door and knocked. “Just a minute,” answered a frail, elderly voice. I could hear something being dragged across the floor. After a long pause, the door opened. A small woman in her 80′s stood before me. She was wearing a print dress and a pillbox hat with a veil pinned on it, like somebody out of a 1940s movie. By her side was a small nylon suitcase. The apartment looked as if no one had lived in it ...

The Sense of Goose

by Dr. Harry Clarke Noyes  ARCS NEWS, Vol. 7, No. 1, January 1992  Next  fall, when  you see Geese  heading South for  the Winter, flying along  in V formation, you might  consider what science has dis‐  covered as to why they fly that way:  as each bird flaps its wings, it creates an  uplift for the bird immediately following. By  flying in V formation the whole flock adds at least  71% greater flying range than if each bird flew on its own.  People who share a common direction and sense of community  can get where they are going more quickly and easily  because they are traveling on the thrust of one another.  When  a goose falls  out of formation,  it suddenly feels the drag  and resistance of trying to go it alone  and quickly gets back into formation to take  advantage of the lifting power of the bird in front....

Freedom of Speech

"DE LIMA: FREEDOM OF SPEECH NOT LICENSE TO RUIN CREDIBILITY" (sic).  I could not agree more!  I would just like to understand though whether this statement is really unadulterated or is it just another attempt at bending “morality” where it is convenient. I seem to remember not long ago the same senator effectively smearing the credibility of some of her colleagues in the government and its institutions, all the while exercising her constitutional right to “Freedom of Speech.”  I have heard claims coming from this Senator about how sure she is that President Duterte is behind DDS and EJK.  In fact, she is so sure that she’s even gone to great lengths of humoring international media with interviews and clamoring for international intervention on our domestic affairs, including imposing sanctions on our nation, all because of the ongoing “government-inspired” EJK.  I have also heard her say, and she is definitely sure about it too, about DOJ fabricating lies...

History: The Battle of Bataan

These are the writings on the wall of the Dambana ng Kagitingan (Shrine of Valor) in Mt. Samat, Pilar, Bataan - a monument built to remember and to celebrate the resilience of the human spirit.  Reading through the inscriptions sent chills to my bones.  It makes me proud to be a Filipino, even more so being a Bataenyo (a native of Bataan).  Let this be a reminder to us all, of the valor and the glory of our roots.  We shall not forget...  "Our mission is to remember."   Photo by Irwin Richard Dizon The Battle of Bataan On this ground gallant men chose to die than surrender. From all corners of the Philippines they came, youthful and brave, to make their last stand in Bataan against an implacable enemy which had marched through Asia. What transpired was a ferocious combat between raw, ill-equipped recruits against seasoned, well-armed troops.

#WeArePhilippines

Recently, we have seen a lot of political disorder in the Philippines that has literally divided, and continue to divide, our nation.  Majority of the government officials, who the Filipino people have chosen to represent their best interests, have misused the trust and the authority that the people have given them to further their individual (and that of their party’s) political interest.  This observation is not only directed at one person or one political party.  Parties and individuals have been hell-bent on criticizing anyone who sits on the other side of the fence.  Privilege speeches and press conferences, under the guise of “at the interest of the Filipino people” have been used to either discredit another official or to defend a “personal attack” directed at them by a member of the opposition.  This has fueled the nation’s divide and has distracted the Filipino people’s sight away from the positive things that currently unfolds right in front of us. O...

Lesson from the Hedgehogs

It was the coldest winter ever. Many animals died because of the cold. The hedgehogs, realizing the situation, decided to group together to keep warm. This way they covered and protected themselves; but the quills of each one wounded their closest companions. After awhile, they decided to distance themselves one from the other and they began to die, alone and frozen. So they had to make a choice: either accept the quills of their companions or disappear from the Earth. Wisely, they decided to go back to being together. They learned to live with the little wounds caused by the close relationship with their companions in order to receive the heat that came from the others. This way they were able to survive.

Lost Wallet, A Great Love Story

As I walked home one freezing day, I stumbled on a wallet someone had lost in the street. I picked it up and looked inside to find some identification so I could call the owner. But the wallet contained only three dollars and a crumpled letter that looked as if it had been in there for years. The envelope was worn and the only thing that was legible on it was the return address. I started to open the letter, hoping to find some clue. Then I saw the dateline–1924. The letter had been written almost 60 years ago. It was written in a beautiful feminine handwriting on powder blue stationery with a little flower in the left-hand corner. It was a “Dear John” letter that told the recipient, whose name appeared to be Michael, that the writer could not see him anymore because her mother forbade it. Even so, she wrote that she would always love him. It was signed, Hannah. It was a beautiful letter, but there was no way except for the name Michael, that the owner could be identified. May...

Welcome to My Standpoint...

I am a Civil/Structural Engineer by education, a Quality Professional by profession, a wannabe-but-chose-not-to-be doctor, a frustrated programmer, a tech enthusiast, an avid sportsman, a hater, a lover, a friend, a son, a brother, a husband and a father. I love music, but music never really liked me -- and so does dancing. I love to write (at least I'd like to think so) but never found the time. I love to draw/paint, but again the busy everyday life took that away from me. The only things that stuck with me throughout the busy-ness of life would be my passion for Tennis, Judo, computers and just about anything that gets plugged in to an electric socket or gets powered by batteries (conventional or solar) -- children's toys included. :) Having said that, I guess I can summarily describe myself as a "Jack of trades, (and hopefully) master of some". I have always believed that knowing a little bit of everything is better than knowing everything about just one thi...

The Problem with Dandelions

A man who took great pride in his lawn found himself with a large crop of dandelions. He tried every method he knew to get rid of them. Still they plagued him. Finally he wrote to the Department of Agriculture. He enumerated all the things he had tried and closed his letter with the question: "What shall I do now?" In due course, the reply came: "We suggest you learn to love them."